hontou ni
16Jun/096

Kannagi OVA – Strangely unsatisfying

Posted by

Actually after a short reflection, it isn't so strange that I didn't enjoy the Kannagi OVA as much as hoped. The OVA suffered from the same issues as the TV series - too much immiscible fat. Note that I enjoyed the 'fatty' bits of Kannagi. Those fun eps were entertaining, even titillating. But with a sudden change in tone as the series rushed towards a hurried end, one can't help but wonder if the storytelling could have been better managed. Looking back, there were at least 2 'fatty' episodes that did nothing to contribute to the overarching story or character development. Sure, I laughed and for many, that should be enough. However, my love for Kannagi's cast compels me to set a higher standard for the series.

The OVA adds to that fat content, only I didn't get as much laughs. Little was added to the overarching plot. There was minimal character development. Neither was there deepened character love (ok maybe Zange but then even her presence is just awesome). For some reasons, Da Capo and SHUFFLE comes to mind when I think of well-integrated storytelling. Both series may be deceiving in that they seem to have a lot of pointless episodes, featuring bishoujos, fanservice or just random silliness. But take it from one who has seen Da Capo countless times and SHUFFLE numerous times that, upon closer inspection, both series compositions are exceptionally coherent and focused. Woven into seemingly mindless harem hijinks are intentional plot or character developments. Such thrusts are what is missing generally from Kannagi.

That said, I would look forward to a season 2 for Kannagi very much. There is much to unveil in terms of plot and a lot of ground to cover for character liaisons. I just hope we'd get marbled beef instead of lard from a 2nd season.

Filed under: Kannagi 6 Comments
4Dec/08Off

Chara Design as a necessarius condition

Posted by


image from gofu.net-comic

Like totali, the latest episode of Kannagi has gotten me rooting [Kabitzin Geass canceller ACTIVATE!] cheering for Tsugumi too. But, in our previous discussions, Stripey won't even place Tsugumi in the running. The reason? He didn't like her hair style and her large forehead.

Filed under: Kannagi Continue reading
15Nov/086

Big Mo’/slow mo

Posted by

In US politics, having the Big Mo' (momentum) has sweep candidates to power. But the British have a saying: 'A week is a long time in politics.' Likewise, for anime series, momentum can diminish, even disappear, over the span of a week or two.

3Nov/0818

4 week into Fall Anime – Final 4 picks

Posted by

4 weeks into the new season and I surprise myself by dropping 2 of my initial picks, yet usher in a new series to chalk up a final tally of 4 on my to-watch list. Indeed, Fall 08 is proving to be a pivotal season in restoring my flagging anime mojo. It's been quite a while since I've been so hyped over so many new series within the same season and I have high expectations that these babies would mature to become anime greats. Haruhi tells me that many of these lovelies would be bagging those numerous year-end blog awards (if they continue their excellent run that is).

In ascending order of love, here's my FINAL 4 Fall picks.

2Nov/084

Charmed by two-faced beauties

Posted by

Hypocrisy is often regarded as an Absolutely Bad Thing. I don't think it's necessarily so. Scholars, like Nils Brunsson, have even argued that it is not only an inescapable part of complex social forms of life but also an essential part that keeps things going. While not as essential to anime, the two-faced beauty is often a treat to watch. And we have two such exemplars this fall.

20Oct/0810

Yuri satisfising this Fall season

Posted by

I've heard that there have been possible sightings of yuri in Mouryou no Hako - looking forward to it if there is.

Thus far the third episode of Kannagi (thanks for the heads up, totali!) had some faux yuri fan service to tease us loser fanboys and provide inspiration for lots of doujinshi. It wasn't really 'yuri' but I lapped it all up anyway - thus, 'satisfising' - being satisfied with an outcome that is sub-optimal.

19Oct/0830

5 Fall series to catch – Stripey’s pick

Posted by

It looks like I wouldn't be reaching for that Spring/Summer stash soon given the promising Fall series I've previewed so far. Here's 5 series I'd be catching in ascending order of love.

5. Kannagi (Seen 1 ep) - Mahou ~miko~ shoujo FTW! While the premise is not all that compelling (yet), I'm intrigued mainly by the Nagi-Jin interactions and curious about the direction their relationship would take. Of course I can't wait to see the birth of Idol Nagi and will pay a kidney (Zyl's kidney - since he got me started on the series) to be at her concert (See also superbly animated OP.)

4. Toradora (Seen 2 eps) - Though initially cautious given that the premise is loaded with cliches, I dropped my guard by the end of ep 2. It would have been easy to go overboard with Taiga tsundere violence or a clumsy/shallow handling of adolescent love that plagues the harem scene. Instead, the audience is treated with well-placed character/relationship developments and a sensitive take on teenage love. The execution for the initial 2 eps has given me much hope for a sweet romance built on the solid foundation of strong characterisation and intuitive interactions. And oh, I absolutely understand why Ryuuji is in love with Kushieda. She's the kind of girl I have crushes on in high school too!

3. Clannad After Story (Seen 3 eps) - Frankly I wasn't impressed with Clannad and that's huge coming from a devoted AIR and Kanon fan. Don't get me wrong, I utterly adore the KyoAni execution. It's the KEY script, I feel, that's weighting down the show. I'm not sure how After Story would be better than its predecessor in this aspect but so far I'm loving every min of KyoAni's anointed touch. Just to add. No one, NO ONE does imouto-moe like KyoAni.

2. Ga rei ~ Zero (Seen 2 eps) - Most shocking opening ep since Soukou no Strain. My jaw had to undergo restorative surgery after it smashed onto the floor as the credits for ep 1 rolled up. To be honest, I wasn't very impressed with GR-Z initially. The conduct of 1st mobile division's assault was laughable. Given their haphazard battle formation and arcs of fire, I was surprised they weren't shooting each other in the backs or taken out in 1 explosion. The subsequent Natsuki bike-fu was nice but way over-the-top. (The tyre-track sutras were a good touch though.) However, all my criticisms on how the animators/writers have little/poor concepts on tactical ops were thrown out of the window in shocking final mins of the first ep. My reaction to ep 2 was similar given that I was groaning about how dumb and unwieldy suitcase-firearms are but those grouses were quickly forgotten with what quickly unfolded after. Gripping stuff. In mostly for the story and cliffhanger ends though.

1. To aru majutsu no Index (Seen 3 eps)

"Would you go as far to hell with me?" That was the most memorable line after 3 eps of ToAru (I'd have to admit I understood very little of ep 3 given that I've seen it raw). There are many things to love ToAru for - beautiful animation, intriguing premise, inspired direction etc but the one thing that stood out was endearing characters. I absolutely love Index and kudos to JC Staff for bringing such a beautiful soul to life. The observant would have noticed that my favourite line in the series (thusfar) was preceded by a very kind but resigned look by Index. It suddenly hit me then that this jolly, seemingly clueless girl was not at all oblivious to her circumstances. She bore a terrible destiny and wished no one to be part of it. It was a rhetorical question which she knew the answer and accepted with kindness. This was reinforced by the fact that she returned to recover her headgear so as not to further involve Touma. A Kotori-class loli!! And what great direction to grant such consistency and depth to a character within a short span of 2 eps. I have high hopes for ToAru and will be looking forward to more Index goodness weekly.

15Oct/0829

Tiger versus Wood

Posted by

I was motivated to pick up ToraDora! after reading about totali's happiness with the first episode but Kabitzin's warning about 'Taiga and her horrible inu comments in the Kugimiya Rie tsundere voice' stopped me in my tracks. It didn't help that Mr Love Power himself developed concerns about the quality of manga adaptation. Overall the consensus on the internets is that the show could be good if Taiga doesn't get too abusive/annoying. If things continue as they did at the end of Ep 2, this could be a very fun and enjoyable series indeed. More power to Ryuuji!

And I just kept thinking that Taiga is Minami Chiaki post-surgical removal of her ahoge. And what we learned when the PPD! gang tampered with Himeko's should have been warning enough!